The National Lacrosse League (NLL) has seen many legendary athletes grace the floor since its inception. These players have not only dominated statistically but also shaped the game and helped elevate box lacrosse’s profile across North America. Here’s a look at the top 10 players in NLL history, ranked for their greatness, consistency, and impact.
1. John Tavares
Career: 1992–2015 | Buffalo Bandits
The all-time leader in goals, assists, and points, John Tavares is the undisputed GOAT of the NLL. With four championships and multiple MVPs, he was the face of the league for over two decades. His lacrosse IQ, vision, and consistency made him unstoppable.
2. Gary Gait
Career: 1991–2005 | Detroit, Philadelphia, Colorado
One of the most dominant forces in lacrosse history, Gary Gait brought creativity and power to the game. Known for pioneering the “Air Gait” move, he won three MVPs and helped revolutionize how the game was played.
3. Dan Dawson
Career: 2002–2023 | Multiple Teams
“The Dangerous One” played 21 seasons and ranks second in all-time assists and third in points. His size, skill, and leadership made him a cornerstone on every team he played for, including two championship squads.
4. Colin Doyle
Career: 1998–2016 | Toronto Rock, San Jose Stealth
Doyle was the heart and soul of the Toronto Rock dynasty, winning six championships and earning an MVP award. A clutch performer with elite passing and shooting ability, he left a lasting legacy in the league.
5. Josh Sanderson
Career: 1998–2016 | Rochester, Calgary, Toronto, New England
“Shooter” Sanderson was a playmaking wizard, finishing with over 1,300 career points. His uncanny ability to find open teammates and control the game’s pace made him one of the league’s top quarterbacks.
6. John Grant Jr.
Career: 2000–2016 | Rochester, Colorado
Possibly the most naturally gifted scorer in NLL history, Grant combined finesse, power, and creativity. A two-time MVP, he delivered countless highlight-reel plays and was a fan favorite across the league.
7. Shawn Evans
Career: 2006–Present
Still active and going strong, Evans has been a consistent scoring machine. He won the MVP twice and is known for his tenacity, vision, and toughness despite being undersized for the position.
8. Mark Steenhuis
Career: 2002–2016 | Columbus, Buffalo
One of the flashiest players the NLL has ever seen, Steenhuis was a high-scoring transition player with incredible stick skills. His MVP season in 2009 and multiple All-Star selections reflect his impact.
9. Brodie Merrill
Career: 2006–2023 | Portland, Edmonton, Toronto, San Diego
Merrill redefined the transition/defensive role, combining elite athleticism with leadership. Widely regarded as one of the best defenders and ground ball specialists in league history.
10. Tracey Kelusky
Career: 2001–2014 | Columbus, Calgary, Buffalo, Philadelphia
A fierce competitor and inspirational leader, Kelusky captained Calgary to multiple championships and earned a reputation for his grit and offensive production. He’s also had a strong post-playing career as a coach.
Honorable Mentions:
- Matt Vinc (top goalie of all time)
- Pat McCready
- Kevin Crowley
- Rhys Duch
- Kyle Rubisch
Conclusion
These players didn’t just put up big numbers—they changed the game, inspired future generations, and built the NLL into the top box lacrosse league in the world. Whether you value clutch performance, jaw-dropping highlights, or career longevity, this list reflects the best of the best in NLL history
