In a move that has left supporters stunned, James Penrice, one of Heart of Midlothian’s standout performers from last season, has announced his imminent departure from the club. The versatile left-back, who was crowned Hearts’ Player of the Year for 2024/25, is reportedly finalizing a transfer to AEK Athens, sending shockwaves through the Gorgie faithful.
The 26-year-old joined Hearts from Livingston and quickly became a mainstay in the starting XI under then-manager Steven Naismith. Known for his consistency, work rate, and attacking contributions from the flank, Penrice was a fan favorite and considered a key figure in the team’s resurgence in the Scottish Premiership.
A Sudden Blow
While whispers of interest from abroad had circulated in recent weeks, few expected Penrice to leave so abruptly. His move to the Greek giants will reportedly see him reunite with former SPFL rival Cyriel Dessers, adding intrigue to what many fans view as a gut-wrenching transfer.
“This one hurts,” said one Hearts fan on social media. “Penrice gave everything for the badge. Losing him just as we’re building something under McInnes is a massive blow.”
Club Response
New manager Derek McInnes acknowledged the emotional weight of the departure, calling Penrice “a consummate professional” and thanking him for his contribution.
> “James was integral to last season’s success, and though we’re disappointed to see him go, we respect his decision and wish him the best,” McInnes stated.
Behind the scenes, Hearts are said to be actively scouting replacements, with reports suggesting the club may turn to the French or Belgian markets for defensive reinforcements.
Fans Left Wondering
The exit raises fresh questions about the squad’s readiness ahead of the upcoming campaign and whether the club can continue to compete at a high level domestically and in Europe. With club captain Lawrence Shankland recently extending his contract, many had hoped the tide was turning toward squad stability—Penrice’s departure now complicates that narrative.
As Hearts press on with pre-season preparations in Spain, the mood among supporters has undeniably shifted. For now, all eyes are on how the club responds in the transfer market—and whether they can find someone who can fill the massive
void Penrice leaves behind.
